Hello, fellow food lovers! Welcome to another gastronomic adventure as we delve into the vibrant culinary landscape of Petoskey, Michigan. Nestled between the cool blue waters of Lake Michigan and the rolling hills of the Midwest, this charming town is a foodie’s paradise, brimming with delicious options that cater to a diverse range of tastes and preferences. It’s time to extend your wish list of must-visit dining destinations!
From perfectly grilled steaks to mouthwatering seafood, and from decadent desserts to the finest craft beers and wines in the region, Petoskey is ready to surprise its visitors at every turn. This picturesque harbor town is not just about its stunning sunsets and historical Victorian architecture; it’s also an exceptional hub of flavor, a place where quality ingredients meet passionate cooking, blurring the lines between food and art.
Whether you’re a lifelong resident of Petoskey or planning your first visit, a thrilling culinary adventure awaits you here. My goal is to guide you through this journey, highlighting the local gems, the hidden treasure spots where locals like to eat, and those high-end places where you can treat yourself with a fine dining experience. Petoskey’s dining scene is as diverse and captivating as its scenic beauty.
So, tighten your seatbelt and get your taste buds ready, as we embark on a delightful journey in uncovering the best places to eat in Petoskey, Michigan. Fancy a farm-to-table feast or in the mood for some quirky cuisine? Our foodie tour of Petoskey caters to all. Let’s dive into the world where every dish tells a story and every flavor sparks a memory. Bon Appétit!
Most Popular Restaurants in Petoskey
First on our list is the Chandler’s – A Restaurant. Located in the heart of downtown Petoskey at 215 1/2 Howard St, this upscale dining establishment is an absolute must-visit. This cozy nook offers a rotating menu that highlights the best of seasonal and local ingredients. Their dishes are a blend of American and French cuisine, with a touch of Asian influence. The Duck Confit and Wild Mushroom Risotto are some of the standout dishes. Pair them with a glass of wine from their extensive selection for an unforgettable dining experience.
Moving on to a more casual spot, you can’t miss the Julienne Tomatoes. Nestled at 421 Howard St, this friendly cafe is beloved for their hearty sandwiches, aromatic coffee, and homemade soups. The locals rave about their breakfast wraps and the towering turkey club sandwich. As a bonus, they also offer gluten-free and vegetarian options, ensuring there’s something for every taste.
Of course, a visit to Petoskey wouldn’t be complete without sampling its seafood. Stafford’s Weathervane Restaurant is the perfect spot for that, located at 106 Pine River Ln. This charming spot serves up the freshest catch from the Great Lakes. Locals and tourists alike can’t get enough of their whitefish dishes, paired with sweeping views of Little Traverse Bay. For a true taste of Michigan, try the planked whitefish – it’s their specialty!
For something a bit more exotic, head over to City Park Grill at 432 E. Lake St. This historic restaurant was once a favorite haunt of Ernest Hemingway and continues to draw in crowds with its hearty fare. Their cuisine is a mix of American and Middle Eastern flavors, resulting in unique dishes like the lamb meatloaf and the hummus platter. Add their craft cocktails to the mix, and you’ve got a recipe for a memorable meal.
Finally, for those with a sweet tooth, there’s Douglas Lake Bar & Steakhouse. Although it’s a bit of a drive at 7314 Douglas Lake Rd – roughly 20 minutes from downtown Petoskey – it’s well worth the journey for their famous desserts. The cherry pie is a must-try, made with tart Michigan cherries and a buttery crust. It’s the perfect ending to a steak dinner at this rustic lakefront restaurant.
These are just a few of the delightful dining experiences awaiting you in Petoskey, Michigan. Whether you’re a fan of upscale cuisine or more of a casual diner, this town has something for everyone. Happy eating!
Most Unique Restaurants in Petoskey
While visiting the charming town of Petoskey, Michigan, it would be a culinary crime not to dine at the Twisted Olive Cafe. This restaurant, located at 319 Bay St, Petoskey, Michigan 49770, offers a rather unique fusion of flavors with a Mediterranean and Middle Eastern influence. The ambiance of the place teems with warmth and casual elegance, making it a perfect stop for solo diners, couples, or even family gatherings.
Their menu highlights include Shawarma-style Chicken, Lamb Kofta Kebabs, and the most amazing Falafel in town. Vegetarians need not worry as there is a bountiful selection of hearty salads and the incredible Mezze Plate. To cleanse the palate, they offer a Citrus Olive Oil Cake that is simply to die for! With an extensive wine list, your meal here promises to be nothing short of a gastronomic delight.
Another culinary gem in Petoskey is the Chandler’s – A Restaurant. Situated at 215 Howard St, Petoskey, MI 49770, this unique restaurant is nestled in the upscale Symons General Store. Chandler’s provides diners a cozy interior, filled with rustic charm and an intimate setting that is ideal for both business or pleasure. The creative menu is a real adventure that changes seasonally, presenting fresh, local ingredients in a sophisticated way.
With dishes like Lobster Risotto, Seared Sea Scallops, and Wagyu Beef Carpaccio, your taste buds are in for a delightful surprise. Enthusiasts should not miss their wine tasting events which showcase an impressive collection of local and imported wines. This unique gem truly raises the bar for fine dining in Petoskey.
Last, but certainly not least, is the famed Petoskey Cheese. Located at 437 E Mitchell St, Petoskey, Michigan 49770, this boutique cheese shop is also a sandwich bar offering an impressive variety of artisanal cheese. From creamy Camembert to sharp Cheddar, and their house-made “World Famous Grilled Cheese”, cheese lovers will find themselves in a veritable paradise.
They also offer regular cheese pairing events, where you can taste and learn about different varieties of cheese paired with the perfect beverage. For those who want to take their love of cheese to the next level, their “Cheese 101” classes are a must-try. This delightful shop is a gastronomic delight that brings a whole new meaning to the phrase “Say cheese!”.
Best Casual Restaurants in Petoskey
Let’s kick off our culinary journey with a stroll down memory lane at the H.O. Rose Dining Room nestled within the historic Perry Hotel at 118 Lewis St, Petoskey, MI 49770. The restaurant exudes an old world charm, complementing the casual up north ambiance Petoskey is renowned for. Sample their signature breakfast menu or if you’re in for lunch or dinner, try the heart-warming Whitefish Chowder made with locally sourced fresh whitefish.
Next up is the City Park Grill, another historical icon located at 432 E Lake St, Petoskey, MI 49770. Once one of Ernest Hemingway’s favorite haunts, this restaurant blends great history with a creative menu that features American classics with an innovative twist. The famous Hemingway Platter – a generous serving of prime rib, chicken, and shrimp – is a must-try for fans of the literary great and foodies alike.
For great food in a laid-back setting, the Beard’s Brewery at 215 E Lake St, Petoskey, MI 49770 hits the bullseye. This local brewery is a beer enthusiast’s paradise, boasting 24 different craft beers on tap. Pair the beers with their mouth-watering pub fare like the Cheeky Chicken BBQ Pizza or the Pretzel Bun Burger, and you’ve got yourself a casual night out that’s everything but casual on taste.
If you’re in the mood for some Mediterranean flavor, make your way to Chandler’s, a boutique restaurant housed in a renovated 19th-century grocery store at 215 1/2 Howard St, Petoskey, MI 49770. The restaurant’s cozy and unpretentious interiors score high on comfort, while its menu is a delightful trip through the Mediterranean. Don’t miss the Saffron Risotto with Shrimp and Scallops for an unforgettable dining experience.
And finally, for those who love the thrill of discovery, a visit to Duffy’s Garage & Grille located at 317 E Lake St, Petoskey, MI 49770 is a must. This automotive-themed restaurant serves burgers and pizzas to die for, in a fun, informal setting filled with motor memorabilia. The “Crankshaft” – their version of the classic Reuben sandwich – is a star on the menu.
No matter what type of casual dining experience you’re after, Petoskey, Michigan, offers plenty of choices to satisfy your taste buds while keeping the vibe relaxed and friendly. So pull up a chair, loosen your belt, and prepare for a memorable gastronomic adventure.
Best Family Restaurants in Petoskey
Sitting atop the list is the quintessential Chandler’s Restaurant. Nestled at 215 Howard St, this unique spot is known for their sophisticated mix of gourmet American and French cuisine. The menu changes with the seasons, supporting local farmers and offering fresh, flavorful selections. Their superb wine list, crafted by their in-house sommelier, is the cherry on top of their culinary masterpiece. With their cozy yet elegant ambiance, dining at Chandler’s promises a memorable experience for the whole family.
Next on our radar is Duffy’s Garage & Grille. Located at 317 E Lake St, this casual eatery is all about good ol’ American comfort food. From custom burgers and piled-high nachos, to their famous pizza and wings, there’s something to satisfy every craving. The restaurant is set in a fun, automotive-themed interior, a hit among kids and car enthusiasts alike. The relaxed atmosphere makes it the perfect place for a laid-back family dinner.
If you’re in the mood for some southern comfort food, be sure to drop by Bobbie’s Kitchen. Situated at 2206 US-31 N, Bobbie’s offers hearty breakfast and lunch options that fill the stomach and warm the heart. Famous for their homemade biscuits and gravy, and fluffy pancakes, this homestyle restaurant is a must-visit for families who love a good, hearty meal.
For a different culinary experience, venture into Tap 30 located at 422 E Mitchell St. This gastropub has a modern industrial vibe and a menu that features a fantastic variety of craft beers, mouthwatering burgers, and unique appetizers. Known for its amazing staff and friendly service, Tap 30 is a fantastic spot for families to bond over a shared love of good food and great drinks.
Last but certainly not least, seafood lovers shouldn’t miss Stafford’s Weathervane Restaurant. Nestled alongside the beautiful Cheboygan River at 106 Pine St, the Weathervane is famous for its fresh local seafood, spectacular riverside views, and historical charm. With its warm, family-friendly atmosphere and delicious menu offerings, dining at the Weathervane is an experience families will treasure.
Best Takeout Food in Petoskey
First on our list is the delightful Chandler’s – A Restaurant located in downtown Petoskey at 215 1/2 Howard Street. Known for their gourmet menu and exquisite wine list, Chandler’s provides a sophisticated takeout experience unlike any other. Their Crab Louie Salad, featuring Fjord Fisheries King crab tossed with baby gem lettuce, gherkins, tomato, cucumber, boiled egg, and classic Louie dressing is a must-try for seafood lovers. The Chandler’s Burger made with Creekstone Farms prime ground beef served with caramelized onion, cheddar cheese, and smoked bacon is another flavorful delight that shouldn’t be missed out on.
Next stop is Noodle Express and Sushi located at 314 E Lake Street. This spot is perfect for those craving Asian flavors. With an extensive menu of Japanese and Chinese dishes, there’s something for everyone in your party. Their sushi options are superb, with the Dragon Roll as a local favorite. It features eel and cucumber topped with avocado and sweet eel sauce. Those who prefer hot food could go for their Orange Chicken or Teriyaki Beef, both coming with rice and vegetables, making it a complete meal.
For fantastic Italian fare, head over to Pietro’s Italian Restaurant located at 2780 Charlevoix Ave. Their homemade pastas and sauces, hand-tossed pizzas, and house specialty dishes like Veal Marsala and Chicken Piccata are simply divine. For those preferring vegetarian meals, the Eggplant Parmesan is a crowd pleaser, as is their Margherita pizza. Top it all off with a Cannoli or Tiramisu for dessert, all available to go.
If you’re looking for some good old American comfort food, we can’t forget about Bob-In Again, located at 1150 Bay View Rd. This charming diner is famous for its root beer floats, burgers, and frozen custard. The Double Decker burger, their own version of a classic “Big Mac,” is a local favorite, with two patties, special sauce, lettuce, cheese, pickles, onions, all on a sesame bun.
Fans of Mexican food will not want to miss Rodrigo’s Mexican Grill at 2160 Anderson Rd. They offer a variety of traditional Mexican dishes, all rich in flavor and freshness. Their Carne Asada Tacos, stuffed with marinated steak, cilantro, onions, and fresh salsa are simply mouth-watering. The Enchiladas Suizas, featuring chicken, green sauce and a decadent topping of melted cheese, is another must-try dish.
Whether you’re craving Asian, Italian, American, or Mexican, Petoskey, Michigan has got you covered! With a selection of diverse and delicious takeout options, you’re guaranteed to find something to satiate your hunger.
What Foods is Petoskey Known For?
If there’s one foodie experience that makes Petoskey, Michigan stand out, it would be its cherry-centric delights. This region is undeniably a cherry country, producing a major percentage of the nation’s cherries each year, and the locals have a knack for incorporating this sweet and tangy fruit into a range of savory and sweet dishes.
When you are in Petoskey, a must-visit spot is Grand Traverse Pie Company, located at 316 E Mitchell Street, Petoskey. This place is renowned for its fantastic cherry pie – tender and flaky crusts filled with a perfect balance of sweet and tart cherry filling. No trip to this area is complete without trying out this tart, sweet, and utterly delicious dessert.
Aside from cherries, Petoskey is also known for its delectable whitefish. Freshly caught from the clear, chilly waters of Lake Michigan, this local delicacy is celebrated in numerous ways across restaurants in the town. Some serve it smoked, others grilled, but you can’t leave town without trying the whitefish at Stafford’s Weathervane Restaurant, 106 Pine River Ln, Charlevoix. Their whitefish dishes are known to leave diners raving, whether you pick the classic grilled fish, or go for the whitefish pate.
While cherries and whitefish may be the most well-known, there’s no overlooking the town’s appeal to pizza aficionados. Turkey’s Pizzeria located at 2501 Charlevoix Ave, Petoskey offers a mouth-watering array of pizzas. While you might be tempted to go for the loaded Meat Lover’s Pizza, the pizzeria’s classic cheese pizza is a delightful surprise with its crisp crust, tangy sauce, and perfectly melted blend of cheeses.
Lastly, satisfy your sweet tooth at Kilwins Chocolates & Ice Cream, 200 E Lake St, Petoskey. It’s a local institution known best for its fudge, in flavors ranging from classic chocolate and vanilla to innovative concoctions like Traverse City cherry and turtle fudge. Pair this with their homemade ice cream and you are in for an indulgent treat.
In conclusion, Petoskey brings a unique blend of local produce, fresh seafood, and artisanal treats to the Michigan food scene. It undeniably offers quite an adventure for the food enthusiast.
Eating Your Way Around Petoskey: A Detailed Food Trip Itinerary
Start your day early with a delicious breakfast at Julienne Tomatoes. Found at 421 Howard St, Petoskey, MI, this breakfast hub is known for its fresh ingredients and savory flavors. Don’t miss their homemade pastries!
After a morning of exploring Petoskey, you’ll be ready for lunch at Chandler’s a Restaurant. This upscale dining spot is located at 215 1/2 Howard St, Petoskey, MI. It specializes in gourmet farm-to-table dishes. Try their delightful seasonal galette.
In the afternoon, visit the famous Kilwins Chocolates for dessert. Situated at 215 E Lake St, Petoskey, MI, Kilwins is renowned for its handmade chocolates and ice cream. A must-try is their signature pecan turtle.
For an early dinner, head over to City Park Grill. It’s found at 432 E Lake St, Petoskey, MI. They’re famous for their wood-fired pizzas and signature cocktails. Do try their lobster mac and cheese, it’s absolutely delectable!
Finish the day with a visit to Tap 30 Pourhouse for a nightcap. It’s located at 422 E Mitchell St, Petoskey, MI. This local favorite offers a wide range of craft beers and cocktails. Try their house brew for a real taste of Petoskey!
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: What are the top places to dine in Petoskey, Michigan?
A1: Petoskey offers an array of eateries that cater to different tastes. Some popular ones include Chandler’s – A Restaurant, City Park Grill, and The Palette Bistro, which offer fine dining experiences. For casual dining and drinks, Beards Brewery, Roast and Toast, and the Petoskey Brewing Company are excellent options.
Q2: Are there any top seafood restaurants in Petoskey?
A2: Yes, absolutely. Petoskey has superb seafood offerings. Apache Trout Grill serves delectable seafood dishes with a beautiful view of the lake. Freshwater Grill is another good choice for seafood lovers, known for their delicious and fresh catch-of-the-day.
Q3: Are there vegan or vegetarian-friendly restaurants in Petoskey?
A3: Yes, Petoskey does cater to the vegan and vegetarian dietary options. The Grain Train Natural Foods Market, Roast and Toast, and The Back Lot are fine examples of places offering vegetarian and vegan menu options. However, it’s always a good idea to call ahead to confirm the available options.
Q4: What are some must-try local dishes in Petoskey?
A4: When in Petoskey, be sure to try out local favorites such as Whitefish, a commonly found fish in the Great Lakes. Cherry-infused dishes and products should also make it onto your tasting list, given Northern Michigan’s renowned cherry production. For dessert, definitely have a slice of the delectable Michigan four-berry pie.
Q5: Any iconic food places in Petoskey with some history?
A5: Definitely! The City Park Grill has a rich history, dating back to 1875. Known to be a favorite spot of Ernest Hemingway, it offers a unique blend of historical ambiance with modern American cuisine. Another iconic location is the Stafford’s Perry Hotel, which has been serving guests since 1899.
Q6: Are there any food festivals in Petoskey?
A6: Petoskey is known for its annual food festivals like the Petoskey Restaurant Week, which usually happens twice a year – once in spring and then in fall. The Taste of the North is another annual festival that showcases the best of Northern Michigan’s food, paired with local beers, and wines.
Q7: Are there any good places for breakfast or brunch in Petoskey?
A7: Yes, several eateries in Petoskey cater to the morning crowds. The Twisted Olive Café and Mim’s Mediterranean Grill are popular among locals and tourists for brunch. For a more classic breakfast experience, American Spoon and Johan’s Pastry Shop never disappoint.
Q8: What are some good high-end dining options in Petoskey?
A8: If you’re up for a fine dining experience, there’s Palette Bistro, a waterfront restaurant with an exquisite menu. Chandler’s – A Restaurant, housed in the city’s old post office, offers a unique combination of ambiance and high-quality cuisine. Additionally, Vernales is another great choice, known for its steak, seafood, and wine collection.
Are you a globetrotter with a passion for discovering unique culinary delights? Do you yearn to uncover the flavors and foodie hotspots that are hidden in cities around the world? Well, you’re in luck! We’ve crafted an array of travel food guides that dive into the gastronomic treasures of many fascinating cities. From the pizza havens of New York to the tapas trails in Barcelona, we’ve got it all covered. So why not take your taste buds on an adventure and check out our collection of food travel guides? You can explore them right here. Bon Appétit!
