As a food enthusiast and self-proclaimed culinary explorer, I’ve spent the better part of my life scouring the globe for tantalizing tastes and savory sensations. Surprisingly, I’ve discovered that you don’t always have to journey far for an unforgettable gastronomic experience. Nestled between the tranquil waters of the Atlantic Ocean and the serene wilderness of the Delaware Seashore State Park, the charming town of Selbyville, Delaware, has a culinary scene that rivals any bustling metropolis.
Entering Selbyville feels like stepping into a serene painting where picturesque landscapes blend harmoniously with small-town charm. In this idyllic setting, the town’s true colors shine through its diverse culinary offerings. From succulent seafood that pays homage to the Atlantic’s bounty, to farm-fresh surprises that celebrate Delaware’s vast farmland, the food scene in Selbyville is an exciting journey for all your senses.
Selbyville’s reach extends way beyond classic American cuisine. Its dining scene is a melting pot of cultures, offering a global food tour without the need for a passport. Traditional Italian dishes, authentic Mexican fare, vibrant Asian flavors, and comforting Southern cooking coexist and collide in this humble town, providing locals and visitors alike with a rich tapestry of dining experiences.
But what truly sets Selbyville apart is its commitment to local sourcing. An impressive number of restaurants make the most of their location with menus that rotate with the seasons, showcasing the freshest produce from nearby farms and markets. These establishments are not just providing sustenance, but actively supporting the local economy and promoting sustainable dining – a testament to the town’s tight-knit community and dedication to preserving its natural beauty.
As we embark on this culinary journey through Selbyville, prepare to loosen your belt a notch or two, and let your taste buds take the lead. Welcome to Selbyville, Delaware—the hidden gem of the East Coast food scene.
Most Popular Restaurants in Selbyville
If you ever find yourself in the charming town of Selbyville, Delaware, you’re in for a culinary treat! This little town is home to some hidden gem restaurants that boast eclectic menus, outstanding service, and inviting ambiance. Here are some of the top spots you can’t afford to miss when in Selbyville.
First, let’s talk about Catherine’s Cafe. Located at 300 Church St, Selbyville, DE 19975, this quaint, homely restaurant is a sanctuary for food lovers who appreciate good old-fashioned comfort food. It’s well known for its hearty breakfast options and its lunchtime delicacies like chicken salad and savory wraps. The Cafe also features a unique coffee bar for caffeine lovers. Catherine’s Cafe hits that sweet spot between quality and affordability that is hard to find.
Craving some authentic Italian? Look no further than Mio’s Pizza Shop. This pizzeria, located at 36252 Lighthouse Rd, Selbyville, DE 19975, serves up some of the best slices in town with a wide array of toppings to choose from. The cozy pizza shop also offers pastas, subs, and other Italian treats. You can taste the love and tradition baked into each dish at Mio’s.
If you have a penchant for Mexican cuisine, El Pacifico is a must-visit. Nestled at 25 Church St, Selbyville, DE 19975, El Pacifico offers traditional Mexican dishes with vibrant flavors and fresh ingredients. From their fajitas to their enchiladas, each plate is a fiesta of taste and texture. The restaurant’s friendly atmosphere and colorful decor add to the overall dining experience.
For seafood aficionados, there’s nothing quite like Captain Mac’s Fish House. Conveniently located at 3720 Lighthouse Rd, Selbyville, DE 19975, Captain Mac’s offers a casual dining environment where you can enjoy a variety of seafood dishes, right from fresh catch to fried delights. Plus, they have a raw bar that serves an excellent variety of oysters, clams, and crab. The lakeside view adds to the charm of this place.
Each of these Selbyville eateries offers its unique take on food and dining experience. So, next time you’re in Selbyville, make sure to treat your taste buds to what these fantastic restaurants have to offer!
Most Unique Restaurants in Selbyville
Let’s dive right into the first gem on the list, Crab Cake Factory Bayside. Located at 37314 Lighthouse Road, Selbyville, Delaware, this restaurant is famous for its award-winning crab cake dishes. Also known for their beachy atmosphere, you’ll feel the sea breeze and the coastal spirit in every bite. From succulent seafood to flavorful cocktails, Crab Cake Factory Bayside promises a feast that’s full of flavor and fun.
Next on our list is the smoky and delicious Bethany Blues BBQ. Positioned at 6 N. Pennsylvania Avenue, Selbyville, Delaware, Bethany Blues BBQ will surely satisfy your cravings for all things meaty and barbequed. Known for its slow-cooked smoked brisket, ribs, pulled pork and chicken, it is a haven for BBQ lovers. The restaurant also boasts a wide array of sauces from tangy to spicy, which adds an extra layer of delight to their dishes.
Another fascinating restaurant is Café on 26, situated at 84 Atlantic Avenue, Ocean View, Delaware, just a short drive from Selbyville. Café on 26 is renowned for their farm-to-table concept, featuring daily specials that depend on the local market’s fresh produce. They are also a celiac-friendly restaurant, offering a wide range of gluten-free dishes that won’t compromise on taste and quality.
Our culinary journey continues to Papa Grande’s Coastal Taqueria. Set at 38929 Madison Avenue, Selbyville, Delaware, this Mexican restaurant blends traditional comfort food with a coastal flair. Expect classic green chili chicken enchiladas, a rich and flavorful carne asada, or a simple yet stunningly tasty street corn. The vibrant atmosphere and creative cuisine of Papa Grande’s will make you feel like you’ve taken a quick trip south of the border.
Last but not least, we have The Good Earth Market & Organic Farm located at 31806 Good Earth Lane, Ocean View, Delaware. With a focus on organic and local ingredients, The Good Earth Market offers a unique farm-to-table dining experience. Besides dining in, you can also shop for fresh produce, baked goods, and local artisan products in their market area. The restaurant also offers vegan, vegetarian, and gluten-free menu options, ensuring there’s something for everyone.
In conclusion, Selbyville, Delaware is a town bursting with gastronomic delights. From seafood to barbeque, farm to table, to Mexican and organic cuisine, you have an array of unique dining experiences waiting to be explored. Whether you’re a foodie or just someone looking for a good meal, Selbyville restaurants promise to serve up something that will satisfy your palate.
Best Casual Restaurants in Selbyville
If you’re in Selbyville and craving some coastal cuisines, you’re certainly in luck. Selbyville, Delaware is home to some amazing casual dining spots that take full advantage of its geographical offering. In no particular order, here are some of the best places you should dine-in.
First on the list is Crabcake Factory Bayside. Located at 37314 Lighthouse Rd, Selbyville, DE 19975, this place is a true gem. With a vast menu offering everything from seafood to steak, their signature crab cakes are a must-try. They are perfect in every sense, juicy, succulent, and full of flavor. Also, don’t forget to try their Bloody Mary – it’s often named as one of the best in the area!
Next up is Foxy’s Bar & Grill. This casual spot, located at 27007 Sand Street, Selbyville, DE 19975, offers an eclectic mix of American classics with a twist. Their burgers are to die for, especially the Foxy’s Special Burger with housemade barbecue sauce. Plus, they offer a great selection of craft beers to pair your meal with.
Third on our list is Mamma Mia Pizzeria. Located at 1 W Church St, Selbyville, DE 19975, this spot serves some of the best pizzas in town. Their hand-tossed dough and fresh, quality toppings are the secret to their success. The ‘Mamma Mia Special’, a pizza loaded with multiple toppings, is a crowd favorite.
If you’re a seafood lover, don’t miss out on The Lobster Shanty. Nestled at 37310 Lighthouse Rd, Selbyville, DE 19975, it’s a seafood paradise. One of the highlights is their Twin Lobster Tails. Steamed to perfection and served with drawn butter, it’s a real treat. You should also try their Lobster Mac & Cheese – it’s well worth the calories!
Finally, for a real treat, visit Catch 54. Located at 38931 Madison Ave, Selbyville, DE 19975, Catch 54 offers panoramic views of the water and a menu that celebrates the seafood of the region. Their Shrimp & Grits are a classic Southern dish that you just can’t miss. And for dessert, their House-Made Ice Cream Sandwiches are simply divine.
These are the best casual dining spots Selbyville, Delaware has to offer. Each offers something unique, whether it’s delicious seafood, heavenly pizza, or classic American fare with an innovative touch. You certainly won’t be disappointed.
Best Family Restaurants in Selbyville
For families visiting Selbyville, Delaware, there are a number of noteworthy dining spots to consider! From comfort food to fresh seafood, here are some of the best family restaurants in this quintessential small town.
First on the list is Old Mill Crab House. Located at 8829 Waller Rd, Delmar, DE 19940, this popular eatery is renowned for its all-you-can-eat crab feasts. Along with the famous crab feasts, they serve a wide variety of appetizers, seafood, steak, chicken, and kids meals to accommodate all your family members. The Old Mill Crab House’s casual atmosphere and shared dining experience make it a perfect choice for families.
Offering a more intimate setting is Smitty’s Better Burger. Nestled at 34053 Dupont Blvd, Frankford, DE 19945, Smitty’s offers a break from seafood without compromising on taste. Known for their handmade burgers, fresh-cut fries, and homemade milkshakes, this restaurant provides a much-loved, classic American dining experience. The kid-friendly environment and menu make it an ideal spot for families.
For all the pizza lovers in your family, there’s Armando’s Pizza. Located at 4 W Church St, Selbyville, DE 19975, Armando’s is a family-owned pizzeria serving a wide range of pizza styles, from thin-crust to deep-dish, along with an array of pasta dishes, subs, and Italian desserts. The pizzeria offers an authentic Italian atmosphere, making dining at Armando’s a fun and memorable family experience.
If your family is in the mood for some Mexican flavor, then Papi’s Mexigrill is a must-visit. Set at 38205 Dupont Blvd, Selbyville, DE 19975, Papi’s offers a mix of traditional Mexican cuisine and Tex-Mex favorites. From savory enchiladas to sizzling fajitas, Papi’s flavorful menu is sure to satisfy everyone in your family. Their vibrant, warm ambiance completes the dining experience.
Lastly, no mention of Selbyville’s dining scene would be complete without discussing Foxy’s Harbor Grille. Located at 10 Marina Plaza, Dewey Beach, DE 19971, Foxy’s offers fresh, delicious seafood with a side of stunning views. With an extensive menu that includes a great selection for kids, this harbor-front restaurant is a favorite among locals and visitors alike.
Whether you are in the mood for seafood, burgers, pizza, Mexican or waterfront dining, Selbyville, Delaware has a family restaurant to suit every palate. Happy dining!
Best Takeout Food in Selbyville
My culinary escapade in Selbyville, Delaware began with Matt’s Fish Camp. Found at 28635 Coastal Highway, this local secret is undeniably a top-tier seafood restaurant, offering some stunningly delicious takeout options. The Lump Crab Cake, crafted with jumbo lump crab meat, is hands-down the best you will ever taste. Don’t forget to pair it with their signature coleslaw for a full-on seafood feast.
Another unmissable spot is Smitty McGee’s Raw Bar. Situated at 37234 Lighthouse Rd, this cozy pub vibe eatery is a heaven for wing and beer enthusiasts. Their famous chicken wings, glazed with your choice of sauce, make a delightful meal if you’re in the mood for some comfort food. They offer curbside pickups for takeouts, which makes it super convenient if you are in a rush. Don’t forget to try their local craft beers, which you can also pick up for a relaxed evening at home.
Next on the list is Fox’s Pizza Den. Located in Lighthouse Plaza, Route 54, this American-style pizzeria is renowned for its mouth-watering gourmet pizzas and wedgie sandwiches. Their Deluxe pizza, loaded with an assortment of vegetables and meats, is bursting with flavors. They do pickup and delivery, so you can enjoy their scrumptious food wherever you prefer.
The final pit-stop in Selbyville must be Off the Hook. Found at 769 Garfield Parkway, this is your go-to spot for fresh, flavorful seafood cooked with an innovative twist. Their Blackened Tuna Bites, tossed in a sweet chili sauce, make for a perfect appetizer or a light main course. They also offer curbside pickup, ensuring your takeout experience is as seamless as possible.
Each restaurant in Selbyville, Delaware, offers unique flavors that are sure to satisfy any food cravings. From classic pizzas to tantalizing seafood dishes, the variety of takeout options available is incredibly impressive. Selbyville truly is a gastronomic delight!
What Foods is Selbyville Known For?
Delaware as a whole hosts a wide variety of scrumptious dishes, and Selbyville shines brightly on its food map. The one food you’re bound to hear foodies raving about is Selbyville’s delectable Rotisserie Chicken. And the top place to savor this mouth-watering dish is at the well-renowned Mountaire Farms.
Located at 55 Hosier Street, Selbyville, Delaware, Mountaire Farms is the go-to spot for locals and travelers alike who have developed a craving for their exquisite Rotisserie Chicken. This isn’t your ordinary rotisserie chicken, it’s a poultry masterpiece that stands out in the vast culinary landscape of Delaware. The chicken is locally sourced, ensuring a fresh and high-quality base for the dish.
What makes the Rotisserie Chicken at Mountaire Farms so special is their secret herb and spice blend. The mix gives the chicken a flavor profile that is unique and absolutely addictive. The chicken is slowly roasted to bring about a perfectly crispy skin, while the meat within remains tender and juicy. Each bite is a mixture of crunch, succulence, and a burst of flavors that are perfectly balanced and utterly delicious.
Another gastronomic gem that sets Selbyville apart is the Blue Crab. And where else to enjoy this but at the beloved Crabcake Factory Bayside.
Nestled at 37314 Lighthouse Road, Selbyville, Delaware, Crabcake Factory Bayside not only provides a splendid seaside ambiance but also serves up the most succulent blue crabs. They pride themselves on their fresh, locally-sourced blue crabs which are prepared to perfection. In case you’re wondering, their specialty is the Maryland Style Crab Cakes, often touted as “Delaware’s finest.”
At Crabcake Factory Bayside, the crabs are hand-picked, tenderly prepared, and garnished with the restaurant’s signature blend of spices. The result is a buttery, tangy, and slightly spicy crab cake that melts in your mouth. The blue crabs are a must-try for every seafood enthusiast visiting Selbyville.
So whether you’re a local, a frequent visitor, or planning your first trip to Selbyville, Delaware, don’t miss out on these culinary wonders. They’re not just meals; they’re a food experience that you’ll remember fondly.
Eating Your Way Around Selbyville: A Detailed Food Trip Itinerary
Start your day at Café on 26, a cozy eatery where you can enjoy a hearty breakfast. Located at 84 Atlantic Avenue, Ocean View, you’ll be greeted by a charming setting with a broad menu offering everything from classic eggs benedict to unique omelets. The café’s coffee is also a must-try.
For lunch, make your way to Crabcake Factory Bayside at 37314 Lighthouse Road, Selbyville. The restaurant is known for its delicious crab cakes that are full of flavor. But don’t forget to try their soup of the day and range of sandwiches. Their deck seating offers a beautiful panoramic view of the Fenwick Island Bayside.
Take a mid-afternoon snack break at Off the Hook, located at 769 Garfield Parkway, Bethany Beach. Known for their fresh and locally sourced seafood, their light bites such as the seafood chowder and blackened fish tacos are perfect to tide you over until dinner.
For dinner, head over to Harpoon Hanna’s at 39064 Harpoon Road, Fenwick Island. With waterfront dining, this restaurant offers a wide variety of dishes, from fresh seafood to prime rib. Don’t miss out on their award-winning crab cakes and specialty cocktails.
End the evening with a sweet treat at Vanilla Bean Bakery located at 34902 Atlantic Ave, Millville. This local bakery is known for its home-baked cakes, pastries, and cookies. Their specialty coffee and different varieties of hot chocolate make a perfect end to the day.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: What are some popular restaurants in Selbyville, Delaware?
A1: There are a number of great places to eat in Selbyville! Some local favorites include Smitty McGee’s Raw Bar, offering delicious seafood and drink specials, The Lobster Shanty, known for their fantastic lobster rolls and relaxed atmosphere, and Cafe on 26, a gourmet spot with a fantastic wine selection. For fans of pizza, check out Fox’s Pizza Den.
Q2: I’m looking for an upscale, fine dining experience in Selbyville. Any suggestions?
A2: If you’re in the mood for gourmet food in a sophisticated setting, you might want to consider dining at the Cafe on 26. This restaurant features chef-driven dishes and a wine selection that would impress even the most devout oenophiles. The ambiance is also conducive for romantic dinners or special celebrations.
Q3: What if I’m on a tight budget?
A3: Selbyville offers plenty of budget-friendly dining options. Fox’s Pizza Den offers great value for money with their delicious pizza offerings. You could also consider visiting Ken’s Bayside Pizza & Subs or Selbyville Deli. Both of these places serve up delicious food at an affordable price.
Q4: Are there any vegetarian or vegan-friendly restaurants?
A4: Those adhering to a plant-based diet will love Our Harvest. This restaurant offers great vegetarian and vegan dishes, made from locally sourced ingredients. Additionally, Cafe on 26 also has a good range of vegetarian dishes on their menu.
Q5: What about gluten-free options?
A5: Dining out with dietary restrictions can be tricky, but Selbyville has your back. Our Harvest and Cafe on 26 both have a selection of gluten-free options on their menu, just inform your server about your dietary needs. It’s always best to call ahead to make sure of availability.
Q6: Are there any unique, must-try food experiences in Selbyville?
A6: Pay a visit to Smitty McGee’s Raw Bar for some authentic local seafood. This is a great spot to savor the area’s remarkable seafood offerings such as oysters and clams. If you’re in town during blue crab season, don’t miss out on this local delicacy. The Lobster Shanty is known for its Twin Lobster Tails — as the name implies, their lobster dishes are a must-try!
Q7: What places are good for breakfast or brunch?
A7: If you’re an early riser or a late brunch enthusiast, check out Armand’s Pizzeria By The Sea. In addition to their incredible pizza, they serve a delightful breakfast. Cafe on 26 is also a great choice for brunch, with their delectable menu items and cozy atmosphere.
Q8: Any good spots for a late-night meal?
A8: If you find yourself craving a late-night bite, head to Smitty McGee’s Raw Bar. They serve food late and their lively atmosphere makes it a fun spot after dark.
Are you a globetrotter with a passion for discovering unique culinary delights? Do you yearn to uncover the flavors and foodie hotspots that are hidden in cities around the world? Well, you’re in luck! We’ve crafted an array of travel food guides that dive into the gastronomic treasures of many fascinating cities. From the pizza havens of New York to the tapas trails in Barcelona, we’ve got it all covered. So why not take your taste buds on an adventure and check out our collection of food travel guides? You can explore them right here. Bon Appétit!
