As the charming cobblestone streets of Nantucket beckon you, so too does the island’s impressive culinary scene. Nestled amidst the captivating seascape, this tiny New England island brims with eateries that will send your taste buds on a delightful journey. From quaint bakeries to elegant restaurants, Nantucket, Massachusetts, offers a gastronomy adventure unparalleled.
Visitors and locals alike can’t seem to get enough of the local seafood, an integral part of Nantucket’s rich food culture. Whether you’re looking for fresh-off-the-boat scallops, hearty clam chowder, or indulgent lobster rolls, you won’t be disappointed. Yet, Nantucket is not all about seafood; it presents a symphony of flavors appealing to every palate.
Indeed, the culinary diversity of Nantucket is as fascinating as its storied history. Once the world’s leading whaling port, Nantucket has effortlessly transitioned into a food lover’s paradise. Today, the compelling array of local ingredients, coupled with the sheer creativity of chefs who push boundaries and continuously innovate, make dining here a wondrous experience.
In the following exploration, we’ll not only guide you to savor the best of Nantucket’s unique seafood but also introduce you to the must-try bakeries, innovative eateries and indulgent dessert spots. So whether you’re planning an intimate candle-lit dinner, a casual lunch, or a delightful morning tea accompanied by pastries, you’ll find a place that appeals to your gastronomic cravings. So pack your bags and your appetite for a food journey like no other—Welcome to Nantucket!
Most Popular Restaurants in Nantucket
Among all the scenic beauty in Nantucket, Massachusetts, what makes your vacation complete is the decadent and delightful food offerings. There are numerous eating joints here that won’t just satisfy your taste buds but also give you an enthralling ambiance, brimming with the local flavors and teeming with the island charm. Here are some top-notch restaurants in Nantucket that truly stand out.
Cru Nantucket, situated at 1 Straight Wharf, Nantucket, is a premier oyster bar offering the island’s finest seafood, wine, and cocktail selections. The view from Cru is simply breathtaking. It’s a perfect romantic dinner joint where you can bond over delectable food while enjoying a divine sunset.
If you want a mix of luxury dining with comfort food, then Galley Beach is the place for you. Located at 54 Jefferson Ave, Nantucket, this beachfront restaurant not only offers a stunning view but also an inviting and chic decor that complements the food perfectly. Offering a blend of French and American cuisines, the menu is as enchanting as the location.
For the die-hard fans of Italian cuisine, Via Mare at Ventuno located at 21 Federal St, Nantucket, is a slice of heaven. The beautiful outdoor seating, under the shade of trees, is a delight in itself. The assortment of antipasti, pasta, and Italian wines is sure to impress even the pickiest eaters.
Seafood enthusiasts, buckle up for a true feast at The SeaGrille Restaurant located at 45 Sparks Ave, Nantucket. The restaurant is a local favorite for fresh seafood, especially the popular clam chowder and their famous crab cakes. With a comfortable, cozy ambiance and impeccable service, you’re in for an unforgettable dining experience.
Don’t forget to check out Sconset Cafe, located at 8 Bank St, Nantucket. With its charming village vibe, white-washed exterior, and delectable offerings, this cafe is the perfect spot for a relaxed brunch or a cozy dinner. Their menu, which changes seasonally, guarantees fresh, local produce prepared with care and artistry.
Whether you’re a gastronome, a food enthusiast, or a traveler looking for a memorable dining experience, Nantucket’s dining scene has something unique and satisfying to offer. Get ready to embark on a culinary journey like none other!
Most Unique Restaurants in Nantucket
Amongst the stunning surroundings of Nantucket, you’ll find a lively foodie scene that encourages plenty of exploration. There is one destination that always seems to stand out from the crowd, the Bartlett’s Farm Truck. Located at 33 Bartlett Farm Road, Nantucket, this mobile restaurant gives a new meaning to the phrase farm-to-table. The Bartlett’s Farm Truck serves delicious, locally grown produce straight from the farm. The menu changes daily, offering a variety of fresh salads, wraps and sandwiches.
The real gem of this place is the fact that you get to enjoy your meal just steps away from the land where your food was grown. The owners of Bartlett’s Farm Truck accredit the freshness and quality of their produce to Nantucket’s unique island climate, which offers an extended growing season and a rich, sandy soil.
Moving from land to sea, another worthy mention is the seafood restaurant CRU. Situated at 1 Straight Wharf, Nantucket, this place is known for its refined yet relaxed seaside dining atmosphere and a commitment to serving only the freshest seafood.
Whether you’re a fan of oysters, lobster, or simply a hearty fish dish, CRU has got you covered. With a raw bar that boasts a wide variety of seafood options and an elegant menu that offers a myriad of options to taste the sea’s bounty, CRU is one of the exceptional spots in Nantucket that seafood lovers must visit.
Lastly, if you’re looking for a truly unique dining experience, you can’t miss the Fig Tree Bakery & Deli and The Juice Bar, located on 29 Centre Street, Nantucket. Famous for their homemade ice-creams and freshly baked goods, Fig Tree has a menu full of options to satisfy any sweet tooth.
This isn’t merely a place to grab a quick pastry or sandwich; it’s a delightful and immersive experience. The inviting interior filled with the aromas of freshly baked pastries and brewing coffee is layered with the nostalgic summer sound of the ice cream maker churning in the background. Fig Tree Bakery & Deli and The Juice Bar are definitely a must-visit when in Nantucket.
So, when you are in Nantucket, don’t just sightsee, let your taste buds embark on an adventure too. Lively and flourishing with an array of unique dining experiences, Nantucket’s culinary scene is sure to impress and inspire.
Best Casual Restaurants in Nantucket
One may think that Nantucket, known for its stunning beaches, iconic lighthouses, and rich history, might be all there is to this coastal gem. But this picturesque island also boasts a vibrant casual dining scene that’s worth every bit as much attention. Here are some of the best casual restaurants in Nantucket, Massachusetts.
Something Natural, located at 50 Cliff Rd, is an island classic. Known for its enormous sandwiches and freshly baked goods, this sandwich shop has been serving the community for over 50 years. Each sandwich is made with bread baked daily on the premises. You can’t beat the lobster salad sandwich on Portuguese bread or the turkey, stuffing and cranberry sauce on whole wheat. Add a homemade cookie or brownie for dessert, and you have a perfect beach picnic.
At 4 Fair St, you’ll find the Corazon del Mar. Offering Latin inspired dishes, Corazon del Mar has found a place in the hearts of both locals and visitors. Their tacos and ceviche are delicious and fresh, while their margaritas are said to be the best on the island. The atmosphere is lively and friendly, making it a wonderful spot for a casual dining experience.
The Chicken Box at 16 Daves St is not just a well-known bar and live music venue, but it also serves some of the best casual food on Nantucket. Open for lunch and dinner, The Chicken Box offers a variety of pub grub, from mouth-watering buffalo wings to juicy burgers. It’s a great place to enjoy some comfort food while listening to live music.
Another must-visit is The Grey Lady, located at 2 Chins Way. Named after Nantucket’s foggy weather, The Grey Lady is a casual seafood joint that offers excellent clam chowder, lobster rolls and fish and chips. The nautical-themed decor adds a charming touch to the overall dining experience.
Lastly, don’t miss out on Lobster Trap at 23 Washington St. Known for its seafood, especially lobster, this casual restaurant has been a local favorite since 1973. They serve their lobster in every way imaginable – from steamed and served with drawn butter, to stuffed into rolls, to baked into pies. You also won’t want to miss their amazing raw bar.
These casual restaurants in Nantucket offer satisfying and delicious food in laid-back settings. Each one provides a unique dining experience that showcases the culinary richness of the island.
Best Family Restaurants in Nantucket
If you’re planning a family vacation to Nantucket, Massachusetts, you must be wondering where to find great meals that every member of your family will love. Luckily, Nantucket is home to several family-friendly restaurants that offer delicious cuisine and pleasant atmospheres. Here are some of the best family restaurants that you should consider:
1. The Brotherhood of ThievesLocated at 23 Broad St, Nantucket, MA 02554, The Brotherhood of Thieves prides itself on providing a unique dining experience that combines 19th-century Wharf Rat ambiance with a broad menu of high-quality food. The menu ranges from seafood to succulent steaks and burgers, ensuring something for everyone in the family. Their clam chowder is a fan favorite and a must-try when you visit. Remember to check out their kids’ menu which features fun and nutritious meals for the little ones. Visit The Brotherhood of Thieves for more details.
2. Sandbar at Jetties BeachThe Sandbar at Jetties Beach, located at 4 Bathing Beach Rd, Nantucket, MA 02554 is a beachfront eatery offering stunning views alongside its scrumptious meals. This restaurant is perfect for families looking for a relaxed, outdoor dining experience. They specialize in seafood, with highlights being the fresh and savory lobster roll and fried clams. Their taco and pizza choices are also worth your attention. Find out more on the Sandbar at Jetties Beach website.
3. Sayle’s SeafoodSituated at 99 Washington St, Nantucket, MA 02554, Sayle’s Seafood is a family-run, seaside shack offering carry-out seafood like clams, lobsters, and scallops. It’s the perfect option for families looking to enjoy picnic-style meals either at the beach or back at their lodging. Their fresh oysters and creamy clam chowder come highly recommended. Visit Sayle’s Seafood for more.
4. American SeasonsAmerican Seasons, located at 80 Centre St, Nantucket, MA 02554 is perfect for families seeking an upscale yet relaxed dining scene. The restaurant changes its menu with the seasons, offering fresh and locally sourced dishes that will excite your taste buds. Kids will love their chicken and waffles or mac and cheese while parents try the roasted duck or the grilled swordfish. More information is available on the American Seasons website.
Nantucket, Massachusetts is a great destination for families, and these restaurants make it even better. They offer tasty and diverse food options, ensuring that even the pickiest of eaters will find something to love. So why wait? Start making your dining plans today!
Best Takeout Food in Nantucket
One of my favorite spots in Nantucket is The Rose and Crown, located snugly at 23 South Water Street. This pub-style restaurant is a local favorite with over 40 years in the business. What strikes me the most about The Rose and Crown is its eclectic menu that offers a fusion of traditional pub food and contemporary American cuisine. Its takeout options are generous and hearty, perfect for a picnic on the beach or a cozy night in.
Start your order with their Royal Nachos or Buffalo Chicken Dip – both are packed with flavors that tease your palate. As for the main course, I highly recommend their Signature Burgers and Fish Tacos. The burgers are juicy and cooked to perfection, and the fish tacos are a delightful combination of fresh, flaky fish and crunchy slaw. If seafood is more your thing, try the Clam Chowder – it’s rich, creamy, and filled with tender clams.
Another gem in the heart of Nantucket is CRU Oyster Bar, located at 1 Straight Wharf. CRU is the island’s premier coastal seafood restaurant famous for its chic nautical ambience. Their takeout menu is full of top-tier seafood selections that will make any pescatarian’s taste buds dance.
Their nationally beloved Shucked To-Order Oysters are a must-try. Sourced from the finest east coast waters, these oysters are fresh and succulent. I also love their Lobster Roll that is generously stuffed with fresh, juicy chunks of lobster. Make sure to try their CRU fries, which are hand-cut and served with a delectable parmesan truffle aioli for dipping.
However, if you’re craving Asian flavors, be sure to check out Sushi By Yoshi, located at 2 East Chestnut St. This family-owned Japanese restaurant has been serving Nantucket’s community for over 25 years. Their takeout menu includes a variety of sushi, sashimi, and other traditional Japanese dishes.
Their sushi rolls are beautifully crafted and delicious. The Spicy Tuna Roll, made with fresh, local tuna, is a favorite, as is the Nantucket Roll consisting of shrimp tempura, avocado, and spicy mayo. If sushi isn’t your thing, the restaurant also offers delightful alternatives such as their teriyaki dishes and noodle bowls that are equally satisfying.
What Foods is Nantucket Known For?
One of the most iconic foods that Nantucket is famous for is the Nantucket Bay Scallop. Known for its sweet, delicate flavor, it is considered a delicacy among seafood lovers. Those who visit Nantucket must try this ocean treasure at its freshest, and one of the best places to do so is at CRU.
CRU, located at 1 Straight Wharf, Nantucket, is a renowned seafood restaurant that specializes in producing the finest oyster bar experience. They serve Nantucket Bay Scallops that are fished in the local Nantucket waters, ensuring their customers have the chance to savour this delicacy in its prime. Their menu showcases the scallops in various preparations, from raw to seared, allowing you to experience its unique flavor in different textures and presentations.
Another traditional food that just can’t be overlooked in Nantucket is Clam Chowder. Nantucket clam chowder has a unique spin to it, distinguished by the addition of quahogs, a type of large clam, which provides the chowder with a more robust and full-bodied flavor. One of the best places to enjoy this hearty delight is at The Club Car.
The Club Car, located at 1 Main St, Nantucket, is an intimate restaurant that boasts a sophisticated dining atmosphere. Their clam chowder is famously creamy and packed with generous chunks of clams, potatoes, and onions. Seasoned perfectly and served with a side of warm, crusty bread, it truly is a bowl of comfort.
Nantucket is also famous for its cranberries and celebrates an annual Cranberry Festival. The local cranberry pies are an absolute treat. A notable place to sample this local dessert is Pi Pizzeria.
While known largely for their pizzas, Pi Pizzeria, located at 11 W Creek Rd, Nantucket, has a surprising hidden gem in their menu – their homemade cranberry pie. This delicious treat is made with local Nantucket cranberries, perfectly blending sweet and tart flavors, topped with a crumbly crust that adds a wonderful texture. This pie is a beautiful representation of the island’s locally-grown produce.
In addition to the seafood, chowders, and cranberries, Nantucket also boasts a long brewing tradition. The Cisco Brewery, located at 5 Bartlett Farm Rd, Nantucket, offers a variety of locally crafted beers, wines, and spirits. Visitors have the chance to tour the brewing facilities, sample the extensive range of products, and enjoy the local music and food trucks on offer.
A visit to Nantucket isn’t complete without sampling the island’s incredible culinary delights. So, whether you’re a seafood lover, a pie enthusiast, or a beer connoisseur, Nantucket has something to cater to all your foodie desires.
Eating Your Way Around Nantucket: A Detailed Food Trip Itinerary
Start your Nantuckett culinary adventure at Black-Eyed Susan’s. Located at 10 India Street, this local hotspot has been serving breakfast and dinner since 1995. Kick off your day with some Pennsylvania Dutch hotcakes or a hearty Nantucket Eggs Benedict. Don’t forget to try their freshly squeezed orange or grapefruit juice!
For lunch, sail on over to CRU, situated on 1 Straight Wharf. This elegant waterside oyster bar offers the island’s freshest seafood, crisp wines, and picturesque views of Nantucket Harbor. Their extensive seafood menu features an assortment of oysters, clams, and lobsters, sure to satisfy any crustacean craving.
Mid-afternoon, treat your sweet tooth at Wicked Island Bakery. Nestled at 147 Orange Street, this bakery is famous for its Nantucket Whaler cookies, cinnamon buns, and mouthwatering buttery croissants. Enjoy a cup of locally roasted coffee alongside the delicious pastries too.
For dinner, make a reservation at The SeaGrille. Located at 45 Sparks Avenue, this family-owned restaurant has been an island favorite for over 25 years. Their menu highlights local seafood with a Mediterranean twist, and the cozy decor makes you feel right at home. Try their Oysters Bienville or the SeaGrille’s baked stuffed lobster for a truly flavorful experience.
Finish your day with a nightcap at Cisco Brewers. Just a short ride out to 5 Bartlett Farm Road, this unique place operates as a winery, brewery, and distillery. They offer a variety of locally brewed beers, wines, and spirits. Look out for their food trucks as well, offering everything from fresh seafood to BBQ. Their live music and vibrant atmosphere make it a perfect spot to end your Nantucket food tour.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: What are some of the popular restaurants in Nantucket?
A1: Nantucket is home to a plethora of diverse and delicious restaurants, such as The Straight Wharf Restaurant, which is known for its fresh seafood. Other popular spots include Cru, a premier oyster bar with waterfront views, and The Galley for its beach-side dining and world-renowned sunset views. The Nautilus, famous for its innovative global cuisine, and The Pearl, well known for its coastal delicacies, are also must-visits when you’re in Nantucket.
Q2: Where can I dine for an authentic Nantucket experience?
A2: To truly eat like a local, visit Millie’s, a casual, rustic restaurant best known for its seafood and Mexican-inspired cuisine. For a classic Nantucket dining experience, you can also go to The Club Car, an old railway car converted into a trendy, sophisticated restaurant.
Q3: Are there any vegetarian or vegan-friendly restaurants in Nantucket?
A3: Yes, there are a few options for vegetarians and vegans. For vibrant, plant-based meals, head to Lemon Press. If you fancy a farm-to-table experience, Proprietors Bar & Table offers vegetarian, vegan and gluten-free options. Also, The Beet serves up creative, plant-based dishes for both vegans and vegetarians.
Q4: Where can I find the best seafood in Nantucket?
A4: Nantucket is famous for its seafood, and you can enjoy the best at The Lobster Trap. Other excellent options are Sayle’s Seafood and The Sandbar at Jetties Beach. These restaurants have a wide variety of fresh local seafood and offer the opportunity to dine with mesmerizing views of the ocean.
Q5: What places are recommended for a romantic dinner in Nantucket?
A5: For a romantic dinner, a visit to Topper’s at The Wauwinet is a must. It offers stunning waterfront views and a world-class menu. Moreover, Company of the Cauldron is perfect for its intimate setting and delicious menu. Another excellent choice is The Boarding House with its outdoor patio and elegant atmosphere.
Q6: Are there places to eat on a budget in Nantucket?
A6: Yes, there are affordable dining options on the island. For tasty yet budget-friendly meals, hit up places like Stubby’s, an easy-going eatery known for its sandwiches and breakfasts. Cook’s Cafe also offers great prices on breakfast and lunch options. Island Kitchen, serving home-style meals, is another affordable option.
Q7: What kinds of cuisine can be found in Nantucket?
A7: Nantucket offers a diverse range of cuisines. You can find everything from exquisite seafood dishes and traditional American fare to global cuisine like Italian, French, and Asian. The island is also home to some great bakeries and dessert shops, such as Petticoat Row Bakery and the Nantucket Bake Shop.
Q8: Is it necessary to make a reservation before dining in Nantucket?
A8: It depends on the restaurant and the season. During the busy summer season, it’s a good idea to book a table in advance, especially for well-known restaurants. However, there are many casual dining spots where you can walk in without a reservation.
Q9: Are there kid-friendly restaurants in Nantucket?
A9: Absolutely! Many restaurants in Nantucket cater to families. The Brotherhood of Thieves, for instance, has a hearty kid’s menu. B-ACK Yard BBQ offers a casual, family-friendly atmosphere, and the kid-friendly fare at The Downyflake will delight your little ones.
Are you a globetrotter with a passion for discovering unique culinary delights? Do you yearn to uncover the flavors and foodie hotspots that are hidden in cities around the world? Well, you’re in luck! We’ve crafted an array of travel food guides that dive into the gastronomic treasures of many fascinating cities. From the pizza havens of New York to the tapas trails in Barcelona, we’ve got it all covered. So why not take your taste buds on an adventure and check out our collection of food travel guides? You can explore them right here. Bon Appétit!
