Greetings, culinary adventurers! I’m excited to share my gastronomic journey in the heart of the American Midwest, the charming city of Carmel, Indiana. This beautifully quaint city, known for its vibrant arts districts and lush green spaces, is a hidden gem within the foodies’ world. Boasting an assortment of top-notch eateries, Carmel offers a fusion of flavors from the four corners of the globe, tantalizing the taste buds of its visitors. Imaginative menus, impressive culinary techniques, inviting ambiences, and warm Hoosier hospitality make dining here a feast for all the senses.
My food exploration in Carmel was nothing less than a delightful surprise. The city, with its small-town charm, has a big appetite for a diverse range of cuisines – from classic American comfort food, contemporary fusion kitchen, authentic international flavors, to the more avant-garde gastronomic creations. As a food blogger, I feast not only on the food, but also on the culinary narratives behind these creations. The stories of the restaurateurs, chefs, and local farmers in Carmel are as rich and diverse as the dishes they serve up.
In the heart of the city, at every turn, there’s a promising eatery ready to welcome you with its aroma, its people, and its food. So tighten your apron, sharpen your knife, and get your napkin ready – we’re about to embark on a culinary journey across Carmel, Indiana, diving fork-first into a world of mouth-watering delights, one restaurant at a time.
Whether you’re in the mood for a cozy breakfast nook, a sunlit lunch spot, an intimate dinner venue, or a late-night dessert haven, Carmel has got you covered. This guide will point you in the direction of the best places to eat in Carmel, Indiana, based on my first-hand experience and countless hours of delicious research. So sit back, brace your appetite, and let’s explore the enchanting world of food in Carmel, Indiana together. Bon appétit!
Most Popular Restaurants in Carmel
When exploring the culinary scene of Carmel, there are certain places you simply must visit. Let’s dive into some top picks that are a must-try on your next visit.
First on the list is Divvy, nestled at 71 City Center Drive. A shared dining restaurant offering a unique concept of dining to Carmel, Divvy’s small plate options allow you to share bites and sips with friends, making the experience social and engaging. Boasting a tempting menu selection from beef sliders to sushi lollipops, there’s something to tantalize everyone’s taste buds.
Next stop, Café Patachou. You can find this gem at 4733 E 126th St. Known as a “student union for adults”, it serves wholesome, locally sourced food in a warm and inviting atmosphere. Offering an array of breakfast and lunch options, the cinnamon toast and omelets come highly recommended.
A visit to Carmel’s The Cake Bake Shop, located at 800 Rangeline Road, will satisfy any sweet tooth. Beyond their exquisite, world-renowned cakes, they also offer a full menu with items like quiches, salads, and sandwiches. Every dish is carefully crafted, using only the finest ingredients.
For a perfect blend of traditional and modern Japanese cuisine, Miyako should be on your list. Located at 12505 Old Meridian St., Miyako offers an extensive menu of fresh sushi, hot entrees, and specialty rolls. The ambiance is both elegant and cozy, perfect for a casual lunch or a romantic dinner.
Lastly, Anthony’s Chophouse at 201 W Main St offers an upscale dining experience. This modern take on the classic steakhouse offers prime cuts of meat, fresh seafood, and a wine collection that was hand-selected from around the world. The ambiance is sleek and contemporary, perfect for a night out.
These are just a few spots in Carmel that you shouldn’t miss out. The city’s food scene has something for everyone, whether you desire a casual brunch, a relaxing lunch, or an elegant dinner. Bon appétit!
Most Unique Restaurants in Carmel
Nestled in the heart of Carmel, Indiana, the booming food scene offers a diverse mix of cuisine, with several stand-out restaurants that are unique in their own right. Let’s get tasting!
Fork+Ale House is a must-visit in Carmel’s culinary landscape. Located at 350 Veterans Way, Carmel, this restaurant serves American fare with a twist, using locally sourced ingredients. Their farm-to-table dishes are not only delicious but also sustainable. The spicy shrimp mac & cheese and the chicken pot pie spring rolls are a testament to their creative spin on traditional dishes.
Another standout is the diverse and flavorful cuisine at Donatello’s Italian Restaurant. Situated at 9 W Main St, this restaurant transports you straight to Italy with their authentic cuisine and cozy ambience. The homemade pasta and sauces are made from scratch, guaranteeing a delicious and fresh meal every time. One cannot miss their signature dish, the lasagna bolognese, which is rich, hearty, and exquisitely savory.
Experience a culinary journey to the Mediterranean at Sangiovese Ristorante. Located at 2727 E 86th St, this restaurant offers an array of Italian and Greek dishes, from robust pasta dishes to crisp, flavorful salads. Their tiramisu is a must-try, with layers of espresso-soaked ladyfingers and creamy mascarpone that create a delightful end to any meal.
For a taste of the East, venture over to Kizuki Ramen and Izakaya. Located at 2450 E 146th St, Kizuki offers authentic Japanese cuisine, with a special focus on ramen. Their ramen is flavorful and fulfilling, with various flavors to choose from. The yakitori and izakaya dishes also provide a delicious taste of traditional Japanese pub food.
Finally, for those with a sweet tooth, a trip to The Cake Bake Shop by Gwendolyn Rogers is a must. Located at 800 S Rangeline Rd, this enchanting bakery-café offers an array of cakes, pies, and pastries, all beautifully crafted and delectable. The shop’s fairy tale aesthetics, complete with chandeliers and pastel shades, make for a unique dining experience. The Earl’s Court Cake, a lemon and raspberry concoction, is a crowd favorite and a must-try.
These unique restaurants in Carmel, Indiana, offer a culinary journey that spans both local and international flavors. Each brings something distinctive to the table, making them truly unforgettable.
Best Casual Restaurants in Carmel
There’s something uniquely satisfying about exploring the culinary scene of Carmel, Indiana. This charming town offers a variety of casual dining options, each promising a delightful experience. Here are some top picks guaranteed to satiate your appetite:
If you’re in the mood for Italian cuisine, Pizzology Craft Pizza + Pub at 13190 Hazel Dell Parkway, Carmel, IN 46033, is a must-visit. The artisanal wood-fired pizzas here, created from locally sourced ingredients, make a decadent meal. The relaxed ambience, with warm wooden interiors and a friendly staff, add to the overall appeal. The ‘Benton’s Smoky Mountain Country Ham’ pizza and the ‘Forager’ pizza are crowd favorites.
For a taste of the sea, there’s Mitchell’s Fish Market, located at 14311 Clay Terrace Blvd, Carmel, IN 46032. This casual spot offers a fantastic selection of fresh seafood and steaks. The menu is expansive and innovative, with options like Chilean Sea Bass and Cedar Planked Salmon stealing the show. The restaurant’s laid-back yet chic atmosphere is perfect for family lunches or dinners.
Bringing Southern comfort food to the heart of Indiana is Divvy, situated at 71 City Center Drive, Carmel, IN 46032. This restaurant offers a unique dining experience where diners are encouraged to divvy up, or share, their meals. The menu consists of diverse, bite-sized dishes, ranging from Jalapeño Corn Grit Cakes to Braised Beef Short Ribs. With its rustic interiors and relaxed vibe, Divvy is a great spot to enjoy a laid-back meal.
Located at 211 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032, Donatello’s Italian Restaurant brings a taste of Italy to Carmel. The menu is packed full of traditional Italian dishes, including homemade pasta and perfectly cooked risotto. The casual yet elegant atmosphere, alongside a friendly and knowledgeable staff, makes this place a go-to for any occasion. Their Veal Piccata and Lobster Ravioli come highly recommended.
Each of these casual dining spots in Carmel, Indiana, offers not just great food but a comfortable setting and welcoming atmosphere – the ideal recipe for a leisurely meal. Whether you’re a fan of Italian, seafood, or southern comfort dishes, Carmel’s culinary scene has something delectable for you.
Best Family Restaurants in Carmel
If you’re craving some authentic Italian cuisine with a modern twist, then Pizzology Craft Pizza + Pub should be at the top of your list. Located at 13190 Hazel Dell Pkwy, Carmel, IN 46033, this spot is great for the whole family.
Pizzology prides itself on crafting their pizza, using only the purest ingredients, from locally sourced veggies to top-grade meats. The kids will definitely enjoy watching their pizza cooked in the classic wood-fired oven. Their menu also includes a variety of pasta, salads, and delicious appetizers. The Nutella pizza is a must-try for dessert!
For a taste of the far east, Muldoon’s is a hidden gem in Carmel. Situated at 111 W Main St Suite 100, Carmel, IN 46032, Muldoon’s serves a perfect blend of traditional and contemporary Irish fare. Everyone in the family will appreciate the welcoming atmosphere, coming as close as possible to capturing the essence of Ireland in Indiana.
Apart from the traditional Fish and Chips, they serve a variety of burgers, sandwiches, and salads, not to mention their hearty Irish Beef Stew. Parents will also love the well-stocked bar offering a variety of local and imported beers. Kids aren’t left out either, with a menu designed just for them!
Heading South, we journey to Mexico at Baja Peninsula. Located at 834 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032, this family-run restaurant serves authentic Mexican dishes guaranteed to transport your taste buds with every bite. It’s a great spot to bring the family and engage in a new culture.
The menu offers a wide range of options, from succulent Carne Asada and Enchiladas to fresh fish tacos and vegetarian fajitas. The restaurant offers indoor and outdoor dining – perfect for those sunny Carmel afternoons. The kitchen also caters to dietary restrictions, with an impressive variety of gluten-free and vegan options.
So whether you’re a local or just visiting Carmel, you’re spoiled for choice when it comes to family-friendly dining. These are just a few of the fantastic family restaurants in Carmel, Indiana, that offer delicious meals and a welcoming atmosphere for all ages. Happy feasting!
Best Takeout Food in Carmel
If you’re looking for delectable fare that doesn’t compromise on taste or quality right in the heart of Carmel, Indiana, fret not, we’ve got you covered. Whether you’re hankering for comfort food, exotic flavors, or gourmet style delights, Carmel is brimming with a variety of cuisines that cater to the tastes and preferences of every food aficionado.
One of the most compelling venues you should try is Divvy located at 71 City Center Dr, Carmel, IN 46032. This avant-garde spot is known for its unique concept of dining. It provides a wide array of delectable small plates, perfect for sharing and sampling an array of diverse flavors. From the sweet corn creme brulee to the bacon dates, Divvy offers an adventurous and exhilarating culinary experience. Their takeout menu is conveniently designed to keep the food fresh and tasty.
Moving towards the exotic nous, consider the Jasmine Thai restaurant located at 12697 N Pennsylvania St, Carmel, IN 46032. This Thai eatery boasts a menu loaded with traditional Thai dishes, each promising a burst of authentic, mouthwatering flavors. The Pad Thai, green curry, and mango sticky rice are crowd favorites. Their takeout service ensures the food stays hot and aromatic, just as you would experience dining in.
If you’re in the mood for comfort food taken to the next level, then you simply must try LouVino. Located at 8626 E 116th St, Fishers, IN 46038, LouVino dishes out Southern-inspired cuisine with an innovative twist. Their chicken and waffles, duck nachos, and bacon wrapped dates are legendary. You can now enjoy these culinary delights in the comfort of your own home with their impeccable takeout service.
For health-conscious foodies, Cafe Patachou, situated at 5790 East Main St, Carmel, IN 46033, is a must-visit. This hip cafe is dedicated to serving nutritious, artisanal food. From gluten-free options to vegan delights, the menu is diverse and wholesome. Their avocado toast, broken yolk sandwiches, and cinnamon toast are not to be missed. We assure their takeout won’t disappoint you as they pay careful attention to packaging and keeping the meal fresh and enjoyable.
Food is a journey, and these Carmel eateries are just the beginning. Each offers a unique take on cuisine, ramping up the traditional takeout experience to new, delicious heights. So go ahead and explore these culinary gems that promise to take your palate on an unforgettable ride.
What Foods is Carmel Known For?
The food scene of Carmel, Indiana might not be as globally renowned as that of New York or San Francisco, but it quietly carries its own unique charm. One might not expect it, but Carmel is particularly known for its delightful gourmet offerings. In this picturesque Midwestern city, you can enjoy quite a number of gastronomic delights from a variety of restaurants riddled around the city.
Starting off our culinary journey, we visit Matt the Miller’s Tavern located at 11 W. City Center Dr, Carmel, IN 46032. A local favorite, this casual, upscale restaurant, and bar serves American comfort food with a twist. Known for their scrumptious Pretzel Bites, this appetizer has been elevated with a sea-salt seasoning and a beer-cheese dipping sauce that simply oozes flavor. It’s an appetizer that you won’t want to share but will have to, simply because it’s too good to keep all to oneself!
And who can talk about Carmel’s food scene without mentioning Bub’s Burgers & Ice Cream found at 210 W. Main Street, Carmel, IN 46032? Home of the “Big Ugly Burger,” Bub’s has been serving mouthwatering burgers since opening its doors in 2003. The “Big Ugly Burger” weighing in at a full pound, is a challenge burger that, if finished, earns you a commemorative photo on the wall. Whether you’re up for the challenge or not, Bub’s offers an array of burger options that are sure to sate any appetite.
Moving on, we arrive at divvy, located at 71 W. City Center Dr, Carmel, IN 46032. It is a sharing plates restaurant and bar that provides a unique dining atmosphere for those who love to try a little bit of everything. With a menu that includes 40+ shareable dishes like Bacon & Eggs, (quail eggs and crispy pork belly), and a wide selection of charcuterie and cheeses, divvy offers an eclectic mix for every palate.
And for those with a sweet tooth, a visit to The Cake Bake Shop located at 800 S Rangeline Rd, Carmel, IN 46032, is an absolute must-do. This is a unique and exquisite bakery that offers an array of sumptuous desserts that not only taste divine but are aesthetically attractive as well. The owner has been featured on many food channels and has even baked for Hollywood stars. Their best seller is their decadent Gooey Butter Cake, which you cannot leave without trying.
All in all, the food scene in Carmel, Indiana is as diverse as it is delicious, serving up everything from gourmet American fare to scrumptious desserts that satisfy the sweetest tooth. And while this article has only just scratched the surface, we’ve highlighted some of the key offerings that make this Midwestern city’s cuisine something that every food lover should experience.
Eating Your Way Around Carmel: A Detailed Food Trip Itinerary
Day 1:Start your day off right at Eggshell Bistro, located at 51 W City Center Dr, Carmel, IN 46032, USA. This charming spot serves specialty brunch items like lavender-infused French toast and curry avocado toast. The exquisite espresso drinks, served in vintage European porcelain, are the cherry on top.
In the afternoon, treat yourself to a flavorful Middle Eastern feast at Sahm’s Restaurant, located at 11505 Allisonville Rd, Fishers, IN 46038, USA. Sahm’s showcases the best of Lebanese and American cuisines. The must-try dishes include their signature coffee cake, and the loaded potato soup.
Day 2:Experience a blend of Italian and American breakfast at Cafe Baby, located at 15009 Greyhound Ct, Carmel, IN 46032, USA. Their menu offers a delightful range of baked goods, smoothies, and coffees plus the house specialty – a sumptuous plate of Eggs Benedict.
For lunch, venture to Donatello’s Italian Restaurant, located at 9 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032, USA. This family-owned eatery is known for its classic Italian dishes and outstanding customer service. Be sure to try their lasagna and tiramisu for dessert.
Day 3:Start early at The Pint Room at 110 W Main St suite 100, Carmel, IN 46032, USA. This craft beer- and burger-focused spot is ideal for a hearty brunch. The Pint Room’s beer cheese burger and extensive craft beer selection is best enjoyed on their outdoor patio.
End your culinary exploration on a high note with dinner at 3UP Rooftop Bar, located at 201 W Main St, Carmel, IN 46032, USA. This upscale hotspot offers a panoramic view of the city along with an inventive menu that includes items like gnocchi carbonara and peach crepes. The farm-to-table plates and signature cocktails are a fitting farewell to Carmel.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q1: What are some popular restaurants in Carmel, Indiana?
A: Carmel has a rich culinary scene, and some of the popular eateries include Carmel’s Bistro 33, Woody’s Library Restaurant, and Matt the Miller’s Tavern, each known for their unique culinary offerings. There is also the Eggshell Bistro that offers amazing breakfast and brunch options, and Pint Room for those looking for great burgers and beers.
Q2: Can I find vegetarian or vegan food in Carmel, Indiana?
A: Absolutely, Carmel offers many options for vegetarians and vegans. Some top choices for plant-based foods include The Local Eatery & Pub, offering a good selection of vegetarian dishes using locally sourced ingredients. Another place is The Garden Table, known for its health-conscious menus. Also, check out Divvy, which has a dedicated, creative vegan menu.
Q3: Are there upscale dining options in Carmel for a fancy night out?
A: Yes, there are several upscale dining options for a fancy night out. Anthony’s Chophouse is a high-end steak restaurant perfect for a stylish dinner. Mezz 42 is another great choice for Italian dishes paired with a phenomenal wine selection. Another note-worthy place is Ocean Prime, offering high-end seafood and steak, with a classy bar.
Q4: What about family-friendly restaurants in Carmel?
A: Carmel is home to a variety of family-friendly restaurants. Bub’s Burgers & Ice Cream is a crowd-pleasing spot, known for big burgers and milkshakes. Another great choice is Rosie’s Place which offers a kid-friendly comfort food menu. If you’re looking for a fun pizza night, consider visiting Pizzology.
Q5: Are there any hidden gems or off-the-beaten-path restaurants in Carmel?
A: Yes, Carmel is also home to several hidden foodie gems. Mudbugs Cajun Cafe is a small place known for its authentic Louisiana-style food. Another interesting spot is Tina’s Traditional Tearoom, perfect for those who enjoy English afternoon tea. Ukiyo, a Japanese inspired restaurant and cocktail bar, is another hidden gem to explore.
Q6: What are my options if I’m craving international cuisine?
A: The international food scene in Carmel is quite diverse. For Mexican food, you can check out Agave Bar and Grill. If you’re craving Italian, consider Convivio Italian Artisan Cuisine. If you’re in the mood for Greek, Santorini Greek Kitchen will not disappoint. For Asian cuisine, check out Kizuki Ramen & Izakaya or Thai Castle.
Q7: Can I find food trucks in Carmel?
A: Yes, Carmel often hosts Food Truck events known as “Food Truck Fridays” in the summer months at the Carmel Gazebo. Here you can find a variety of food trucks with a wide selection of cuisines – from BBQ to Mexican, Asian, and more. Keep an eye on the Carmel city events page for updates.
Q8: Are there any good places for dessert or sweet treats in Carmel?
A: Yes, for those with a sweet tooth, Carmel has several excellent dessert stops. For ice cream, the popular Bub’s Ice Cream is a must-try. The Cake Bake Shop offers an array of delightful cakes, pies, and pastries. If you’re a chocolate connoisseur, visit Xchocol’Art for handmade, gourmet chocolates.
Are you a globetrotter with a passion for discovering unique culinary delights? Do you yearn to uncover the flavors and foodie hotspots that are hidden in cities around the world? Well, you’re in luck! We’ve crafted an array of travel food guides that dive into the gastronomic treasures of many fascinating cities. From the pizza havens of New York to the tapas trails in Barcelona, we’ve got it all covered. So why not take your taste buds on an adventure and check out our collection of food travel guides? You can explore them right here. Bon Appétit!
